Olivia Culpo may have just welcomed her first child, but she’s already teasing fans about whether baby No. 2 could be on the way sooner rather than later.
After giving birth to daughter Colette Annalise McCaffrey with husband Christian McCaffrey last month, the former Miss Universe is opening up about where she stands on expanding her family.
“When they already start asking about baby number 2,” Olivia wrote on an August 21 TikTok, which showed her sweetly cradling her newborn while her mother-in-law, Lisa McCaffrey, strolled past the nursery pushing a wicker baby basket.
“Anything off the trolley, dear?” Susan lip-synced in the clip, before Olivia jokingly mouthed back, “No thanks. I’m all set.”
But the 33-year-old admitted she might not be quite as set as she claims.
“Jokes on me,” she captioned the video, “because I’m already asking myself the same thing.”
The funny moment comes just weeks after Olivia and Christian became first-time parents. The couple tied the knot in June 2024 after five years of dating, and parenthood has already kept them on their toes.
@oliviadangerculpo jokes on me because I’m already asking myself the same thing 😂🥳
Shortly after giving birth, Olivia made headlines when she clapped back at critics who poked fun at her hospital packing list — which included her own pillows and flameless candles.
“I got roasted a little for what I packed—but I ended up using it ALL,” she explained via Instagram Stories on July 15. “When you’re recovering from a C-section and stuck in the hospital for 3-4 plus days, having your creature comforts is no joke.”
Christian, meanwhile, has been balancing football season prep with new dad life. The San Francisco 49ers running back admitted that leaving his wife and newborn behind for training camp was tough.
“I feel guilty at times,” he told NFL Network on August 5. “I’m sleeping well in the hotel bedroom while she’s doing the dirty work. But I’m super thankful for her and she’s doing an incredible job.”
Of course, Olivia has been open about wanting kids with Christian long before Colette arrived. Back in October 2023, she joked on TikTok that she wanted to “rip out” her IUD and “start trying immediately” after getting married.
Her sisters have also been her biggest cheerleaders throughout her journey to motherhood. Sophia Culpo playfully teased Olivia’s not-so-subtle attempts at hiding her baby bump, while Aurora Culpo told People she had no doubt her younger sister would excel as a mom.
“I know she’s going to be a really loving mother,” Aurora shared in October 2024. “I know that she’s going to be very prepared. I think she’s going to have everything in place. Probably already picking out her children’s preschool. At the moment she’s probably already on the waitlist.”
